.png)
Yoga Knees: Can the Knee Travel Over the Toe?
Edited & Updated from "Yoga - Madness or Meditation" (Available on Amazon)
Disciple: I am always told the knee should never travel over the toe. Many yoga teachers swear by this fundamental anatomical “rule.”
This type of teaching, where the knee should "never" pass the toes, has become a staple in many yoga classes, especially in verbal cueing. It's often touted as an absolute truth—something that applies to everyone, at all times, in all circumstances. But have you ever heard the wise old saying, "The moment someone is absolutely certain about something, they are almost always absolutely wrong"?
We need to unpack this belief, examine its origins, and place it within a more accurate understanding of human movement. Particularly, we need to consider the concept of athletic capacity and how this relates to yoga asana, human anatomy, and biomechanics.
Understanding Athletic Capacity
Athletic capacity refers to the body’s ability to tolerate stress during movement. Whether you’re chasing after your kids or busting out dance moves in a Zumba class, your body is absorbing and responding to stress. Each of us has a unique threshold—our muscles, joints, tendons, and ligaments can bear only so much stress before they react, adapt, or, in extreme cases, give way to injury.
So, what is your body’s athletic capacity? Specifically, what stress can your knee joint tolerate? From my years of teaching, practicing, and studying human movement, it’s clear that the knee joint is capable of far more than most yoga teachers, with limited anatomical training, understand.
The next time you’re in a yoga class, take a moment to observe your fellow students. Notice the diversity: different body shapes, sizes, genders, experiences, and levels of athleticism. You’ll see everything from highly muscular individuals to ex-dancers to people with joint limitations. Each body is unique in its structural anatomy and capacity to withstand different loads. Some people naturally have more flexibility or strength in certain areas. Others have more limitations or restrictions.
Given this diversity, we need to question the validity of saying “the knee should never go past the toe” as a universal, one-size-fits-all rule. Is this directive considering the anatomical and physiological differences of every student in a class? More importantly, does it take into account the unique loads that each individual knee can safely tolerate?
Knee Anatomy and Biomechanics: The Science Behind the Movement
The knee is an incredibly complex joint, primarily functioning as a hinge joint—designed to allow for flexion and extension. But, anatomically speaking, it’s not a pure hinge like a door. The knee has a slight rotational capacity, allowing for small degrees of movement in multiple planes. This rotational element is crucial when understanding how the knee functions dynamically in activities like yoga, running, or even walking up and down the stairs.
ANATOMY BIT -
Let’s dive deeper into the anatomical components of the knee to understand its movement:
Bones and Joints: The knee is primarily a hinge joint formed between the femur (thigh bone) and the tibia (shin bone). The patella (kneecap) lies on top of the joint, gliding over the front as the knee moves. The fibula, a smaller bone on the outside of the leg, provides stability. The femur and tibia meet at the tibiofemoral joint, which is where most of the knee’s flexion and extension happen.
Ligaments: The knee’s stability is primarily provided by four major ligaments—the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), medial collateral ligament (MCL), and lateral collateral ligament (LCL). These ligaments control the knee's forward and backward motion (in the case of the ACL and PCL) and its side-to-side motion (MCL and LCL).
Cartilage and Menisci: The knee also contains cartilage and menisci that provide cushioning and shock absorption, protecting the bones from friction and impact. The menisci, in particular, play a critical role in distributing the forces that pass through the knee joint during activities like walking, running, or practicing yoga.
Muscles: Several major muscle groups control knee movement, most notably the quadriceps (which straighten the knee) and the hamstrings (which bend the knee). Additionally, the calf muscles and hip muscles indirectly affect the knee’s position and stability. Proper muscle engagement and strength are crucial to the knee’s ability to safely absorb and tolerate load.
So, can the knee travel over the toes safely?
Absolutely! The human knee is designed to move forward. Its natural hinge mechanism, coupled with its ability to slightly rotate, makes it perfectly capable of moving past the toes in a variety of functional movements, including yoga poses like lunges, Warrior poses, and squats. The idea that the knee should never pass the toes ignores the intricate biomechanics of the joint and its capacity for natural, forward movement.
The more nuanced question should be, how far can the knee go forward safely? This depends on multiple factors: the load being placed on the knee, the length of time in that position, and the individual’s capacity to handle that stress. In a yoga class, where external loads (like weights) are absent, and most of the load comes from body weight and gravity, the knee can often move past the toes without issue.
Take, for example, a student with shorter feet relative to their tibia and femur. Anatomically, their knee may need to travel forward to maintain balance in poses like Warrior I or II. Trying to restrict their knee from passing their toes would create unnecessary tension in the hips or lower back, resulting in compensation elsewhere in the body.
Why the Knee-Over-Toe Rule Doesn't Hold Up in Yoga
This "knee should never pass the toes" cue originated from the world of strength training, specifically during the 1970s when sports scientists were analyzing the safest way to squat with heavy weights on the back. Their research did show that when the knee moves forward, the knee experiences increased shear force—a combination of sliding forces acting parallel to the knee joint. Under heavy load, these forces can increase the risk of injury, particularly when the knee is not properly aligned.
However, this research was conducted in the context of lifting heavy weights—far from what we typically encounter in yoga, where the resistance is body weight and gravity alone. The "knee-over-toe" guideline became a quick and easy way to reduce risk when teaching group fitness classes to large, varied groups. It was a general precautionary measure rather than a scientifically-backed, universally applicable rule.
In the context of yoga, it’s vital to remember that the absence of external resistance significantly reduces the amount of stress placed on the knee joint. Poses like Warrior I, lunges, or deep squats (Malasana) are bodyweight movements. They challenge the muscles and joints, but not in the same way as loaded barbell squats. Thus, it’s far less risky for the knee to travel forward over the toes.
The Role of Gravity, Load, and Individual Variation
In biomechanics, we also need to account for the role of gravity and load when evaluating movement.
In yoga, the body's load in poses like Warrior I or II is relatively low. The quadriceps and gluteal muscles bear most of the load. Allowing the knee to travel over the toes increases the demand on the quadriceps, but this is not necessarily dangerous—it’s a natural response to the increased angle of knee flexion.
The key factor is individual variation: How much load can your knee tolerate? What is your athletic capacity? Some individuals have the muscular strength and control to let their knees pass their toes without issue, while others may need to develop that strength over time. Blanket statements like “never let your knees pass your toes” ignore the complexities of individual capacity.
The critical point is alignment. As long as the knee is tracking properly with the foot—meaning it’s not collapsing inward (valgus) or bowing outward (varus)—then allowing the knee to pass the toes is a natural, biomechanical movement. Issues arise when the knee joint moves out of alignment, which compromises stability and increases injury risk.
Muscle Engagement in Knee-Over-Toe Movements
In poses where the knee travels forward, like in Warrior II, the quadriceps play a significant role in stabilizing the front leg. As the knee moves forward, the quadriceps engage more intensely to control the movement. When students report feeling discomfort, it's often due to muscular fatigue rather than joint pain. Many students misinterpret this fatigue, thinking their knee is in danger, when in reality, it's the quadriceps doing their job to support the knee joint.
By allowing the knee to move forward, we're not only engaging the quadriceps more fully, but we're also teaching the body how to distribute load effectively. Instead of forcing the hips or lower back to compensate for restricted knee movement, we let the knee do its natural job, which is to bend, move forward, and absorb force.
As Dr. Jacob Harden, a chiropractic expert, points out, "It's not about whether the knee goes forward, but about whether the stress is adequate or excessive." In other words, knee movement in yoga needs to be assessed based on the individual’s ability to tolerate the load rather than applying arbitrary, one-size-fits-all rules.
Conclusion: Move With Intelligence, Not Fear
The idea that "the knee should never pass the toes" may have originated in strength training, but it has no place as an absolute rule in yoga. Every body is different, and every knee is capable of different degrees of movement. Instead of fearing movement, we should embrace it—safely, intelligently, and with an awareness of our own body’s capacity.
Trust your body’s wisdom, and remember that safe movement is about alignment and individual capacity, not rigid rules.
Zahir Akram - Eternal Seeker
---------------------------------
Interested in deepening your practice or teaching skills?
Our online training courses are now available, offering comprehensive content on anatomy, biomechanics, and yoga philosophy. These courses are designed to support students and yoga teachers in their continued development.
For more information on our online courses, mentoring or to book in-house training, email Zahir.
